Will Carver's Kill Them with Kindness (2025) reimagines the premise of a virus engineered to promote altruism, reminiscent of David Brin's 1987 short story The Giving Plague. Set against the backdrop of the COVID-19 pandemic, the novel weaves a speculative conspiracy narrative involving global powers and scientific manipulation. The story explores the development of a virus designed to foster kindness and cooperation, while darker forces exploit the ensuing chaos for their own ends. The setting works well because the conspiracy theory provides answers to the unanswered questions of who benefits from the overblown fear and panic world-wide that persists now. None of the preventative care measures had any effect on the spread of covid-19 in humans, and the silly, theatrical, useless prophylaxis measures caused long-lasting, world-wide destruction to society, economics, politics, healthcare, education, etc.
The narrative draws strength from its initial focus on philosophical themes, particularly through characters who embody collectivist ideals, offering a compelling lens on human behavior under crisis. However, the antagonists lack depth, their motivations reduced to simplistic malevolence. The plot, initially engaging, veers into implausible territory with the introduction of exaggerated technological elements, undermining its early promise. The grim resolution feels heavy-handed, failing to fully reconcile the tension between free will and biological determinism.
Compared to Brin's nuanced exploration of symbiosis and agency, Carver's novel ambitiously tackles similar themes but stumbles due to its reliance on far-fetched plot devices and underdeveloped characters. The setting and philosophical undertones captivate, but the execution falls short.
Rating: 2/5 stars.
No comments:
Post a Comment