While browsing the 2025 Hugo Award nominations, I encountered The Imposition of Unnecessary Obstacles by Malka Older and decided to read it. Unfortunately, the novel fell far short of expectations, suffering from significant flaws in its science, characters, and world-building.
The scientific elements in the book lack credibility, undermining the story's foundation. Equally disappointing are the characters, none of whom I found engaging or relatable. Background characters, in particular, feel one-dimensional, adding little depth to the narrative. The novel's world-building, especially its economic systems, appears poorly constructed and unconvincing.
The overuse of recurring symbols and metaphors—such as the "cuppa" tea rituals, comfort food, and lesbian sex scenes—feels heavy-handed and detracts from the storytelling. These elements, intended to enrich the narrative, instead become repetitive and tiresome.
On a positive note, the depiction of academic politics stands out as a strength, offering sharp and insightful commentary. This aspect, however, cannot redeem the novel's broader shortcomings.
I cannot recommend The Imposition of Unnecessary Obstacles due to its weak science, unlikable characters, and flawed world-building. Readers seeking a compelling sci-fi experience should look elsewhere. 2/5 Stars
No comments:
Post a Comment